Jason Hawrelak Criteria for Healthy Gut – Revisited

This is an update Jason Hawrelak Criteria for Healthy Gut. His criteria is based on percentages and used by medical practitioners around the world. I have three significant collections of samples and decided to find out how these percentages translate to percentile for each lab.

They are similar and not similar. For example 50% of people will have low Akkermansia using uBiome while Biomesight increases it to 77%. Alistipes — are never out of range for Biomesight while 90% of people using uBiome would be too high.

Taxa NameTaxa RankPercentageuBiome PercentileOmbre PercentileBiomesight Percentile
Akkermansiagenus1 – 548 – 8071 – 9177 – 93
Alistipesgenus0 – 0.30 – 100 – 330 – 100
Bacteroidesgenus0 – 200 – 320 – 480 – 45
Bacteroidiaclass0 – 350 – 240 – 400 – 45
Bifidobacteriumgenus2.5 – 578 – 9178 – 8790 – 95
Bilophila wadsworthiaspecies0 – 0.150 – 320 – 430 – 44
Blautiagenus5 – 1015 – 6032 – 7224 – 69
Desulfovibriogenus0 – 0.150 – 460 – 420 – 72
Escherichia colispecies0 – 0.10 – 1000 – 750 – 88
Eubacteriumgenus0 – 150 – 1000 – 990 – 100
Faecalibacterium prausnitziispecies10 – 1580 – 9550 – 6946 – 69
Fusobacteriumgenus0 – 0.010 – 400 – 660 – 72
Lactobacillusgenus0.01 – 123 – 939 – 7546 – 99
Methanobrevibactergenus0 – 0.010 – 70 – 330 – 33
Oxalobactergenus0.01 – 10 – 10038 – 10035 – 100
Prevotellagenus0 – 250 – 1000 – 890 – 88
Pseudomonadotaphylum0 – 40 – 520 – 760 – 54
Roseburiagenus5 – 1051 – 8685 – 9681 – 95
Ruminococcusgenus0 – 150 – 1000 – 9810- 95

This post is intended to illustrate that percentages cannot be determined by one lab and applied to another. Percentile appears to be more robust.